Review Article
The Relationship between Suicide and Quality Communication: A Literature Review
Received Date: May 01, 2019; Published Date: May 23, 2019
Abstract
Suicide is the 10th leading cause of death in the United States, which was 42,773 suicides in 2017 [1]. Female nurses are 4 times more likely to commit suicide than females in other careers [2]. In 82% of nurses surveyed, they reported a high risk for work- related stress [3]. Nurses work long hours and have little control of duties with high workloads and demands, which can cause stress and burnout.
Nurses are at risk for job stressors that can lead to mental health concerns. Nurse managers need to participate in the exchange of information and feelings to develop an understanding between one another [3]. The need for a healthy work environment is essential to the survival of medical professionals. Without quality communication among nurses and their managers, the suicide rate of nurses will remain high [4].
Increased stress can increase the risk of suicide and emotional pain [5]. When a health professional disengages and faces burnout at work there is an increased risk for self-harm [3]. Healthcare professionals experience high expectations and pressure at work while trying to maintain high quality care and productivity [3].
A study of 10,000 suicide cases from 2001-2012 was analyzed [2]. Healthcare professionals accounted for 3.8% of those deaths [2]. Approximately 9.6% of nurses will experience an episode of major depression [4]. Depression is a main contributory factor related to suicide [5]. Nurse managers’ role should include suicide prevention. There is a lack of education for nurse managers to prevent suicide [2]. Action needs to be taken to reduce the high rate of healthcare professionals’ deaths.
There are several factors that increase the risk of suicide. According to the Centers for Disease Control [6], risks for increased risk of suicide are a family history of suicide, previous suicide attempt, history of mental health disorders, alcohol abuse, drug abuse, feeling of hopelessness, and feeling of isolation. According to the Centers for Disease Control [6], protective factors to decrease suicide are clinical treatment for mental and physical disorders, treatment for substance and alcohol abuse, and support by community and family. By communicating concern for an individual can promote treatment and quality communication to decrease the risk for death by suicide.
Depression and other personality disorders increase the risk for suicide [7]. Providers encounter many patients with mental health concerns and need to know how to provide safe and quality care to prevent suicide. Learning how to use the theory of planned behavior promotes successful use of emotional pain communication, which is essential to intervene in suicidal behaviors and actions.
It can be challenging to communicate. Honest communication brings people together and bad communication leads to stress and errors [8]. This reinforces the need for quality communication in healthcare. Quality communication is a connection between two individuals, which requires listening, understanding and not being judgmental [5].
Qualities of good communication are being free from distractions, maintaining eye contact, being supportive and expressing a non-judgmental attitude. Quality communication is a two-way process of reaching a mutual understanding. The participants exchange information and feelings where they can develop a shared meaning [5]. When a nurse manager has high quality communication techniques with staff nurses and co-workers, there can be a decreased stress level [5].
Nurses feel cared for when leaders recognize them as a whole person [5]. Nurses need to speak more directly to one another on issues that personally and professionally matter [5]. Nurses and managers need to take time to ask themselves and one another if they are mentally and physically okay. Collaboration is helpful in promoting a positive work environment.
Nurses are trained to help others and tend to neglect their own mental and physical health needs [5]. This reinforces the need to eliminate or decrease the stressors that increase the risk of nurse suicide. Communication can open doors for individuals who are suffering emotionally. A literature review was conducted to answer the question, do female nurses who have quality communication with their managers, have similar suicide rates, compared to female nurses who do not have quality communication with their nurse managers?
Communication Research Literature Review
Cochrane and CINAHL databases were selected to search for studies related to communication and suicide. The search was limited to select articles from 2008-2018. The studies were reviewed and selected based on effects related to communication and suicide behaviors. (Table). The first research study reviewed examined message content to promote suicide intervention [9]. This study reviewed the literature on suicide and the theory of planned behavior (TPB). The research discussed how the theory of planned behavior communication can decrease the risk of suicide [9]. Research related to suicide, suicide behaviors and the TPB was collected on the internet and databases [9].
The theory of planned behavior (TPB) is an intrapersonal theory that is utilized to predict behavioral interventions and behaviors [10]. In the TPB, there are three constructs that enrich the behavioral intention, which are designed to be the strongest predictor of behavior [10]. The three constructs in the TPB are behavioral attitude beliefs, normative beliefs, and control beliefs [10]. Refer to the Appendix for a more detailed description of the TPB.
Findings suggest the TPB will increase providers understanding of patient’s emotional pain [9]. Findings also suggest the TPB trained health care workers can intervene when working with suicidal individuals or situations [9]. This reinforces the need for mental health support and suicide awareness training for medical staff. Refer to Table for detailed information regarding research.
Table 1: Review of Literature Studies of Communication and Decreased Risk of Suicide.
Implications for practice are to implement teaching and utilization of the TPB model and to teach warning signs of suicidal intentions to reduce the risk of suicide. Another implication for practice of the study is medical professionals need to be trained how to use the TPB to decrease suicidal behaviors [9]. Theory of planned behavior in practice can benefit the provider and the patient by promoting safety and suicide reduction [9].
The second research study reviewed sought to identify factors that impede and promote emotional pain communication [11]. Emotional communication is the ability to understand one’s feelings, which promotes a successful conversation [11]. Being emotionally aware of one’s feelings improves the quality of communication. Emotional pain communication is between those at risk for suicide and mental health care providing clinicians’ ability to intervene in suicidal behaviors [11]. The study was a qualitative design composed of individualized and focus group interviews. The study took place in the United Kingdom. There were 9 female patient participants, aged 27-58 years with more than one hospital admission related to suicidal actions [11]. There were 26 female mental health staff in the study. Findings suggest unsuccessful communication can deter communication between provider and patient. Another finding suggested due to the complexity of emotional pain communication; training staff can increase the quality of emotional pain communication with patients [11].
Limitation of this study was lack of male participants and publication bias. Implications for practice include co-bearing and empathizing with patients can decrease emotional pain, which allows for communication and suicidal behavior treatment [11]. Another implication for practice is medical professionals need to learn and understand emotional and suicidal behaviors to prevent and decrease suicide rates [11].
Suicide and depression are a worldwide concern. According to the Anxiety and Depression Association of America [12], approximately 75% of individuals with mental health disorders are not treated with 1 million individuals committing suicide yearly. This reinforces a strong need for the TPB education among providers to decrease the risk of suicide. Medical providers can save lives with increased knowledge and understanding of patient’s emotional pain [9].
Evidence Strength Levels
The research articles were chosen within the last 10 years from academic journals. According to Polit & Beck [13] level of evidence, one of the resources that was selected was a literature review with a level V and the other resource was individualized and focus group interviews with a level VII classification. The resources utilized carried good quality level of evidence based on their classification. The studies recommended that by training staff in emotional pain communication can increase the quality of communication and can decrease the risk of suicide. Additional research needs to be done due to limited research related to communication and suicide.
Recommendations
Managers need to be trained in emotional pain communication and support their staff to decrease suicide among nurses [9]. Leadership needs to be supportive and avoid stigmas related to mental illness to prevent nurses from avoiding their mental health issues [6]. Managers acknowledging that a staff member has emotional pain concerns can decrease the risk of nurse suicide [9].
The theory of planned behavior can intervene in suicide behaviors and actions by understanding patient’s emotional pain [9]. Emotional pain is a harsh mental activity that is undesirable and possibly damaging [9]. Emotional pain can stem from a death, trauma, divorce, job loss and/or elevated stress levels. Emotional pain communication occurs when individuals engage in a conversation and one of the individuals is experiencing emotional pain. Emotional pain communication is complex and challenging.
Unsuccessful communication can damage communication between two individuals. Training medical staff emotional communication skills can increase communication quality [11]. Theory of planned behavior can help managers learn to communicate with staff that is experiencing emotional pain. Empathy and sharing of feelings can decrease emotional pain, which allows from quality communication and suicidal behavior intervention and treatment [9].
During the search for research it was very challenging to find research for the topic. CINHAL and Cochrane database were to locate research related to communication and suicide reduction. The Stettler model of evidenced based practice was used to determine the possibility of applying the TPB emotional pain communication to decrease suicide [14]. The Stettler model established that emotional pain communication needs to be practiced among medical staff. The risk of not implementing emotional pain communication may lead to increased risk of medical staff having poor communication. The benefits of implementing emotional pain communication can improve communication quality and intervene in suicidal behaviors.
To implement emotional pain communication medical staff, need to be ready to receive education. Education for emotional pain communication will occur in a lunch and learn. The education for emotional pain communication will be an annual mandatory requirement for all medical staff.
In the education lunch and learn, staff will learn about the TPB. Medical staff will also practice using emotional pain communication with one another. Skits will be done in front of the lunch and learn room, so all participants can access response to emotional pain communication experience. Once education is completed all medical staff will apply emotional pain communication in practice. In six months, there will be a reevaluation of the implementation of emotional pain communication and adjustments will be made according to results. Reeducation on emotional pain communication will be given during new medical staff orientation and annually for all medical staff.
Acknowledgement
None.
Conflict of Interest
No conflict of interest.
References
- Hannah Nichols (2017) Top 10 leading causes of death in the United States.
- Brennan B (2016) Female doctors and nurses at least three times more likely to commit suicide: study.
- Parkash V (2018) American health-care workers are committing suicide in unprecedented numbers.
- Jennifer Thew RN (2018) Nurse Suicide Is Real. Don’t Ignore It.
- Judy Davidson, Janet Mendis, Amy R Stuck, Gianni DeMichele, Sidney Zisook (2018) Nurse suicide: Breaking the Silence.
- Centers for Disease Control (2018) Suicide: risk and protective factors.
- Braquehais MD, Eiroa-Orosa FJ, Holmes KM, Lusilla P, Bravo M (2016) Differences in Physicians ‘and Nurses’ Recent Suicide Attempts: An Exploratory Study. Arch Suicide Res 20(2): 273-279.
- Fraser Sherman (2019) What are the benefits of effective communication in the workplace?
- Shemanski Aldrich R, Cerel J (2009) The development of effective message content for suicide intervention: theory of planned behavior. Crisis 30(4): 174-179.
- Hackman CL, Knowlden AP (2014) Theory of reasoned action and theory of planned behavior-based dietary interventions in adolescents and young adults: a systematic review. Adolesc Health Med Ther 5: 101-114.
- Dunkley C, Borthwick A, Bartlett R, Dunkley L, Palmer S, et al. (2018) Hearing the Suicidal Patient’s Emotional Pain. Crisis 39(4): 267-274.
- (2018) Anxiety & Depression Association of America. Anxiety and depression.
- Polit DF, Beck CT (2017) Nursing research: Generating and assessing evidence for nursing practice 10th edn, Lippincott Williams &Wilkins, Philadelphia, USA.
- Melnyk BM, Fineout-Overholt E (Eds). (2015) Evidence-based practice in nursing & healthcare: A guide to best practice (3rd edn). Lippincott Williams &Wilkins, Philadelphia, USA. ISBN 9781-4511, pp. 9094-9096.
-
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
